The Rev. Frank
Logue
King of Peace Episcopal Church
Kingsland, Georgia
October 30, 2005
A Bunch of Hypocrites
Matthew 23:1-12
The reading for this morning always makes me nervous.
Jesus warns against people who sound a lot like me. Notice Jesus’ words about
someone who loves to have the best seat in the synagogue. As the one who sits
in the only carved wood chair at the front of our church, that comment hits
home.
Then Jesus says these hypocrites like to be called
“Rabbi” and goes on to warn against calling anyone “Father” except your Father
in Heaven. Doesn’t this make “Father Frank” a hypocrite? Maybe. But at least
Jesus says to do as I say do, even if you do not do as I do.
To confront the issue of hypocrisy head on, I do think
there is a reason why non-Christians refer to Christians as a bunch of
hypocrites. They say this because we are hypocrites. Hopefully, not all the
time or even intentionally. But a hypocrite is, after all, someone who says
one thing and does another. Well, we Christians are want to say they we want
to live as Jesus lived. We want to lead Christ-like lives. Then in our all too
human ways we fall short of that lofty goal. So, of course, someone will
occasionally cry foul and someone will be there say that we are living
hypocritically. It happens.
So, yes, I am a hypocrite. But I hope it is not because I
sit in a seat of honor or because some folks who attend church here and the
kids in the Preschool call me “Father Frank.” To better understand what is
going on in this passage, I think it helps to know a bit more about the
practices Jesus to which Jesus is referring. Then we can look back on his
words to see how they may apply in practical ways to our own assembly.
Jesus specifically targets the Pharisees and Scribes in
his critique. The Pharisees taught how to follow the details of the 613
commands found in Moses’ Law. This is why Jesus would say that “They tie up
heavy burdens hard to bear and lay them on the shoulders of others.” And yet
because they did not help others in the practical details of carrying out that
Law in their daily lives, Jesus also said that the Pharisees and scribes would
not “lift one finger to assist someone.”
In particular, Jesus seemed most upset that they
practiced their faith in such a way as to get others to notice them. For
example, Jesus said that they made their phylacteries broad and their fringes
long. A phylactery is a ritual object tied to one’s forehead and arm when
praying Morning Prayer. Phylacteries come as a pair of small black boxes
containing a parchment of scripture within them. The words of Exodus 13:3-10
and Deuteronomy 6:4-9, 11-16 and 11:13-21 were written on the parchment, to
follow the words of the scripture itself. For example, Deuteronomy 6:4-9
says,
“Hear, O Israel! The
Lord is our God, the
Lord is one! You shall love the
Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all
your might. These words, which I am commanding you today, shall be on your
heart. You shall teach them diligently to your sons and shall talk of them
when you sit in your house and when you walk by the way and when you lie down
and when you rise up. You shall bind them as a sign on your hand and they
shall be as frontals on your forehead. You shall write them on the doorposts
of your house and on your gates.”
Originally taken metaphorical, these passages came to be
taken literally as Jews bound the Word of God to their foreheads and arms,
just as they came to place a Mezuzah on the doorpost containing the same
scripture. Both the Phylacteries, are typically called tephillin today, and
the mezuzah are to be a daily reminder to put this scripture into action.
In a course I took in seminary on Judaism, the Rabbi put
on the tephillin in front of us saying the prayers as he went. Wrapping
the straps around his hand in a pattern he created the letter shin on his
hand, shin as in Shaddai, one of the names of God. As he made this
pattern, the Rabbi prayed words from the Prophet Hosea,
And I will betroth you to Me forever. I
will betroth you to Me through righteousness and justice, through
lovingkindness, mercy and faithfulness; and you shall know the Lord.
The Rabbi told us what an important daily reminder it was
for him that he binds himself to God in love and is in the process wrapped in
God’s love for him. Then he placed the prayer shawl on his head, with the
phylactery or tephillin still protruding out the front as he took up
the other prayers for his personal devotion of morning prayer.
The prayer shawl, which is called a Tallit in
Hebrew, follows the command from Numbers 15:39 which called for fringe on the
corners of you garments to remind you to follow God’s teaching. Specifically,
when you see the fringe you are to remember to follow what God has taught,
“and not follow after your own heart and your own eyes.” The tzitzit or
fringe are knotted in a particular way to symbolically represent the number
613. Originally these fringe were on regular clothing. In time they were
attached only to the prayer shawl as people ceased to make their robes with
corners on which to tie the fringe.
Today, Orthodox Jews still wear the prayer shawl daily to
keep this command about having fringe on your clothes as a reminder to keep
God’s commands. Though the only sin it still serves as a reminder not to
commit is now adultery as the shawl is worn by the Orthodox as an undergarment
day to day and only as an outer garment when taking part in prayer services.
Historically women did not pray using phylacteries or
wear a prayer shawl in prayer, though in contemporary times many Jewish women
have added these practices to their prayer lives.
I bring all this up to let you know that the tradition
Jesus talks about is a living tradition in which many people find their
connection to God strengthened. Jesus never taught not to wear phylacteries or
to have fringe on your garments. And as Jesus Jewish opponents never publicly
accuse Jesus of dropping these important forms of Jewish piety, we assume that
Jesus routinely wore a prayer shawl and that he would have prayed using
phylacteries at some points.
Jesus specifically preaches against having a
Holier-than-Thou attitude through literally wearing your faith on your sleeve.
To make your phylacteries broad is to make sure everyone knows what a Holy
Person you are. The same applies to fringe as long fringe was another way of
showing yourself to be a Pious Person. Those who bought big honkin’
phylacteries and long-fringed prayer shawls were cultivating a lifestyle that
cried out “Look how Holy I am! God asks me for advice.”
So in this context Jesus also warned about taking seats
of honor in the synagogue and taking on titles that put you in the place of
God. This may be a bit of self-justification, so you are free not to but what
I will say next. I grew up in the Church of God where everyone was bother or
sister so in so. The idea of “Father Frank” was anathema in that tradition.
Yet, the Apostle Paul referred to himself as spiritual father to those for
whom he had care and there is this other tradition of referring to your
spiritual leader as father, with the idea that they are a father, not The
Father.
I was uncomfortable with this when on my ordination I
came to work here in Camden County. But following other traditions, kids
started calling me Mister Frank and that did not seem right either. So after
prayer, I realized that for me, “Father Frank” is acceptable as long as no one
has to use that title and everyone is quite clear that Father Frank is not the
Father as in the Trinity. I’ve never experienced anyone coming close to
getting confused on that point, and have found it quite easy to be humble
about having a lot of kids calling me father. And as I am charged with seeing
that they are raised in the Christian faith, I find the use of the title
consistent with Paul’s writings and Jesus’ teaching.
The same goes with my fancy wooden chair up front.
Sometimes referred to as the Bishop’s chair for it is the one our Bishop uses
when he comes. The carvings even bear a resemblance to his hat, which is a
pointed mitre. As an aside, we got that chair after I visited Bishop Louttit’s
house. He and Jan use these chairs as dining room chairs. I told Jan I thought
one would make a nice presider’s chair for King of Peace and she found me the
catalog. So it’s not an antique, but a newly acquired dining room.
The proper term is presider’s chair. We use it because it
is good for the assembly to clearly know where the designated leader is
sitting. Yes, it is a place of honor, but the honor does not belong to me. It
is for whoever is leading the service for as long as they lead the service.
When the Bishop or anyone else leads on a given Sunday, I move to another
seat. More justification I know. But it also shows that the seat isn’t mine.
It is not my place, but the presider’s place.
I say this to show how we do need to think through our
traditions when they seem to be at odds with Jesus’ teachings. What we really
need to see is that though we don’t wear phylacteries big or small or fringe,
long or short, what Jesus warns against can still be a problem for a bunch of
hypocrites like us. Remember we are still the ones who say we want to live to
be more and more like Jesus. So what can we learn?
First we must note that Jesus did pray using phylacteries
and did wear a shawl with fringe. So Jesus is not preaching against forms of
piety, of having ways we show devotion to God. What Jesus is clearly preaching
against is practicing your piety, which is personal, in a way intended to show
others what a great Christian you are.
A more up to date example, might be for Jesus to warn
against carrying around a really big Bible. Jesus would certainly advocate
regularly reading the Bible, but that would not justify waving around a big,
ol’ Bible to show everyone what a great Christian you are. The problem would
not be the Bible anymore than it was the seat of honor, the title of Rabbi, or
the fringe on the shawl. The problem is an in-your-face holiness designed to
convey to others that your real address is heaven and you just slum around
here to do a favor to God.
In contrast to that Jesus taught, “The greatest among you
will be your servant. All who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who
humble themselves will be exalted.”
This is really just fair warning from Jesus. Wave the big
Bible in someone’s face to tell them how far from God they are, and you will
find yourself humbled and the person you got all red faced at may well be
calling you a “hypocrite.” Or you could more humbly live out your faith by
living the best way you know how, reading your Bible as you can, praying and
trying put that scripture and life of prayer into practice. Then when God
creates natural opportunities, you can speak of your faith and even bring the
Bible into it. But that is a more humble approach and one that is more likely
to be compelling to co-workers rather then repelling.
Don’t put yourself ahead of others, as you are no better
than they in God’s eyes anyway. Don’t chase after honors, for the sake of
making yourself look big or important. In God’s eyes you are already important
and the only way to place yourself ahead of others is by becoming their
servant. If you want to become more Holy, to become more like Jesus, the path
is through service. Look not only to your own needs, but also to the needs of
others.
This is what Jesus taught and lived and he calls us to
follow in his path of service.
Amen.